In my last post, I addressed an article from Champion City News about EF Hutton. In that post, I addressed Champion City News and EF Hutton as if they were separate entities.
But I'll be honest... from the outset, I have suspected that Champion City News is not an independent news outlet. In fact, it has been my assumption that EF Hutton is behind the news site.
I made no such assertion in my last post, and when people asked me about it in Facebook comments, I refrained from speculating. I did not want to make assertions that I could not support (because, I apparently have more journalistic integrity than Champion City News does).
Sure, there were the rumors I'd heard from others, but those were all hearsay.
And yes, it's true that people have contacted me since my post circulated on Facebook... some of whom claim to have been at the company when EF Hutton launched the new website... but these eyewitnesses have asked to remain anonymous. Anonymous tipsters are often helpful, but they sometimes feel inadequate for proving anything beyond a shadow of a doubt.
So, I've had my suspicions, but I have not been able to draw any tangible connection between Champion City News and EF Hutton.
Until I read the Terms of Service.
I found something interesting, and I would like to share it with you. Before I do, I'll need to give you just a tiny bit of background information.
We are going to talk about Meggalife. What is Meggalife? It's a product/service/platform created by EF Hutton. This is no secret, there have been press releases about it and EF Hutton celebrates Meggalife as their brand. But, if you'd like to see proof, here's a picture from the Meggalife website linking Meggalife to EF Hutton. (I'll be sharing some screenshots here... if you have trouble reading the text in the images, you can click on each picture to enlarge it in most browsers, or follow the link to see the source).
Meggalife.com/pages/how |
These Terms also mention Megga, Inc. Megga, Inc. is a subsidiary of HUTN, Inc. HUTN, Inc. is the parent company of EF Hutton. You can read their most recent financial statement to see what I mean (this can be accessed by clicking here).
HUTN, Inc Financial Statement |
HUTN, Inc Financial Statement |
I noticed an interesting link between the Champion City News website and EF Hutton's Meggalife website. And, believe it or not, it all came from the Terms of Service. (Terms can be accessed here for CCN and here for Meggalife).
Let's start small. Take a look at EF Hutton's Meggalife Terms of Service. When were they last updated?
Meggalife Terms of Service Page on Feb 16, 2018 |
The Meggalife Terms of Service were most recently updated on November 7, 2017. I wonder when the Champion City News Terms of Service were last updated.
Champion City News Terms of Service Page on Feb 16, 2018 |
Wow! Imagine that! The Champion City News Terms were also updated on November 7, 2017. What an interesting coincidence! (The domain registration says the site was registered on Jan 18, 2018, but obviously this content was prepared prior to that date)
Fun little coincidence there, but does it really prove anything? Not really. I mean, these are totally separate websites, with totally separate purposes, operated by totally separate entities. Aren't they? It's not like there are any other similarities here...
For example, take a look at how Meggalife is described in their Terms of Service:
Meggalife Terms of Service Page on Feb 16, 2018 |
Meggalife is described as "a diverse suite of internet products and services, all under the Meggalife banner." Champion City News is something else entirely. The Terms of Service over at Champion City News describe the news organization as...
Champion City News Terms of Service Page on Feb 16, 2018 |
Hmmm. I guess Champion City News and Meggalife must have more similarities than I realized. Both of them seem to be a diverse suite of internet products and services, all under one banner. I thought CCN was just a news site, but apparently it's got a lot more going on.
Despite their apparent similarities up front, we all know that Meggalife and Champion City News have different functions. Meggalife is a product that allows users to accumulate points using a variety of social media platforms. These points can later be turned into cash value for a 401(k)! This is why the Meggalife Terms address matters such as points and 401(k)s.
See?
Meggalife Terms of Service Page on Feb 16, 2018 |
That's not the case with Champion City News. That site only exists to share news articles! There's no reason to expect the Champion City News Terms of Service to mention accrual of points or a 401(k). Right?
Champion City News Terms of Service Page on Feb 16, 2018 |
Oops.
I don't want to make any unfounded accusations here... but it is beginning to seem like Champion City News copied and pasted the Terms of Service from EF Hutton's Meggalife website, changing out the name of the product for the name of the news publication.
It's almost as if someone took the text from one website and inserted it into the other website, probably assuming that no one would notice. (After all, who reads the Terms of Service?)
That's not the only time it happens. Here are two side-by-side shots, discussing the accrual of Megga Points on EF Hutton's website and/or Champion City News Points on the CCN website.
Meggalife Terms of Service Page on Feb 16, 2018 |
Champion City News Terms of Service Page on Feb 16, 2018 |
Here's the thing. I've linked both pages here in this post (again, you can read CCN Terms here and Meggalife Terms here). Except for the names, the wording is exactly the same from beginning to end. Someone has copied EF Hutton's Meggalife Terms of Service and pasted them onto the Champion City News website.
This next one is my favorite. Look at this Warranty Disclaimer from EF Hutton's Meggalife.
Meggalife Terms of Service Page on Feb 16, 2018 |
Champion City News Terms of Service Page on Feb 16, 2018 |
Yeah. Drink that in. Champion City News "are" making you aware.
I think I have driven the point home, but since we're all here, take a look at one final example. Once again, you can see the font change to lower case in the second example, while the rest of the language remains the same.
Meggalife Terms of Service Page on Feb 16, 2018 |
Champion City News Terms of Service Page on Feb 16, 2018 |
Does this prove, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that EF Hutton is the owner and administrator of Champion City News? Is this the smoking gun? No, not exactly.
All it proves is that the administrator of Champion City News, for some reason, has borrowed the Terms of Service from EF Hutton's Meggalife website.
But it's odd, isn't it?
Why does this matter?
Why am I even talking about this? Who cares?
Because, if this is true, it means we have a company in our midst which is actively trying to disseminate fake news in our community.
That term (fake news) gets thrown around a lot these days... so much so that I typically avoid using the phrase.
But I have reason to believe EF Hutton is behind Champion City News. Not only that, I have reason to believe they are, possibly as recently as Friday Feb 16th, actively seeking opportunities to stir up false stories by contacting members of the community for comment.
Of course, you can decide for yourself what course of action might be best. For me, steering clear of Champion City News entirely feels like the safest bet.
No comments:
Post a Comment